What to Expect from Lineages'
Professional Research
Many people who hire a genealogist for the
first time have no idea what to expect. Commonly, those with no
prior knowledge of the research process believe that for the average
fee of $1200.00, their lineage can be extended as far back
as
possible. Many believe that doing genealogical research nowadays
is as simple as pushing a button on a computer, which will then
print out all the information needed. The truth is: both notions
are false.
Genealogical research is a time-consuming process,
requiring special knowledge and skills that few people have developed.
Searching in several different record sources is difficult, painstaking
and costly. Even searches which are not so involved take time. Computers
are just beginning to be used for storing genealogical information,
and it is doubtful that the lineages of all mankind will ever be
stored in computers for easy access in research. However, research
alone in only part of the genealogical project. The entire process
is a very involved one, consisting of the following:
- Analyzing data received from
the client. The information that accompanies a research request
must be carefully sifted in order to fully understand the research
problem, ancestors of interest, reliability of the information provided,
areas where the ancestors lived, and other factors to ensure that
prior research is not duplicated. It is important that the client
furnish the genealogist with copies of all data previously
acquired by the family or other genealogists. This way, the client
can avoid disappointment over duplication of previous research or
being told what he already knew about his ancestors.
- Determining the objectives
of the client. This important step, done with the assistance
of the client, ensures that the professional does not focus on a
portion of the ancestry that is not of interest to the client.
- Surveying the types of record
sources available. The Family History Library of the LDS
Church has the largest collection of records in the world. However,
that repository does not hold everything that might be needed to
solve a research problem or to extend the ancestry of a client.
An analysis of what can and should be done in the Family History
Library is essential, along with an analysis of the records maintained
in other libraries or public records offices.
- Designing the research process.
Next, the genealogist constructs a research design which outlines
the search of the most pertinent records available to meet the client's
objectives. Those records that should contain the most valuable
information are top priority. Less applicable sources will be searched
in order of descending value in the time allotted.
- Searching the records.
The genealogist will identify and obtain the record, then search
for mention of the ancestor of interest and take notes or photocopy
that document. If records are not available in the local repository,
letters will be written to the appropriate person or agency, requesting
needed information. A check to cover costs of the service and documents
must be included with the letter.
- Evaluating the records.
Each piece of evidence found in a document must be carefully examined
to determine its value, the leads it provides in identifying additional
ancestors, and its accuracy. It must be determined whether it agrees
or conflicts with information already gathered.
- Compiling family group records
and lineage charts. Although simple on the surface, this
is a time-consuming process that consolidates a great deal of information
into a manageable, understandable format. Each document extracted
from the records must be culled for the information that appears
on these forms. Without the lineage chart or family group record,
the genealogist would have to wade through mounds of reports to
know exactly where research had taken the extension of the client's
ancestry.
- Reporting on research.
As important as quality research is, it is the research report which
tells the client exactly what was done and how, and the conclusions
of the findings. Every report should be accompanied by photocopies
of the documents to which it refers. It should also tell the client
what more can be realistically done to extend the lineages during
future projects, without promising the impossible.
- Putting the information on
paper. Each research report, family group record, lineage
chart, letter and all supporting material must be typed. Each page
must be checked and cross-checked to ensure accuracy. Invoices must
be prepared, copies must be made and filed, and the project must
be mailed to the client.
Other Things To Be Aware Of:
Post-1920 U.S. research is difficult. Due to privacy laws, there
will not be many records in libraries that pertain to ancestors
born in the U.S. after 1920. Thus, it is extremely important that
the client provide as much information as possible, such as names,
birthplaces, residences, moves, children, etc., about ancestors
who lived or were born after that time. This information is critical
to the success of the research project.
- Previous data is a must.
Again, in order to avoid duplication of research already done,
it is important for the client to tell the genealogist in advance
everything he knows about the ancestor and provide all the data
previously acquired. If the client's records are incomplete, it
may be necessary to search the same records again to obtain a
complete picture of the family in the document.
- There are no guarantees for
any one record. There are instances where an ancestor
lived in an area for only a short time, and he will not be found
in that record. The genealogist can only search the available
records and share the client's hope that the needed information
will be found in that record. In addition, please realize that
there is a finite amount of easily retrievable information on
any given ancestor. The further back one goes, the fewer records
available. The more that has already been found or is already
known, the less there remains to be discovered.
- There are limits to lineage
extension. Extending a person's lineage depends on many
factors, including availability of records for the areas where
the ancestor resided, frequency of the family's moves, the commonalty
of the surname, the ancestor's station in life, the preponderance
of evidence with which to determine relationships, and many lesser
factors. Most lines can only be traced back as far as the beginning
of the civil or ecclesiastical registration, generally about 1650.
Some lines, particularly those of ancestors with a higher station,
can be traced back further if they link with lines of royalty
and landed gentry.
- Expect slower progress on
large city research. Research in New York, Philadelphia,
Chicago, and other large cities takes much more time and effort
than, for example, that in a small, rural county in the Midwest.
Hundreds of volumes of records must be considered in the large
city, and unless the family of interest was prominent, there may
be no mention of them in local histories. Thus, progress is usually
slower.
- Evidence is not 100% proof.
Seldom, if ever, can 100% proof be obtained in genealogical research,
since most relationships are based on material and circumstantial
evidence found in the available records. The evidence is evaluated
and conclusions are drawn, based upon the preponderance of that
evidence. When carefully pieced together, all evidence points
to a relationship or a non-relationship.
When the client presents the genealogist with a large amount of
previously extracted information, he should understand that it
will take considerable time and effort to properly examine, evaluate,
and commit it to memory. If the material is voluminous, it could
take an entire research period. However, it is critical that the
genealogist see that evidence and evaluate it in order to avoid
duplication. Clients who have been researching their surname for
years and have memorized the factual data pertaining to every
person by that surname who lived in this country should not expect
the professional genealogist to ingest this knowledge in a single
research period.
- Family traditions may or
may not be true. Many clients provide lengthy stories that
have been handed down through generations which may or may not
be accurate. Some parts of the tradition may be valid, while others
are not. In some instances, the entire tradition has no foundation.
Each piece of tradition must be tested and evaluated, then either
accepted or rejected, based upon evidence in the records. The
client should be aware that undocumented traditions handed down
through several generations are subject to change and interpretation.
Although these stories are surely treasured, the genealogist seeks
only to clarify the tradition and build an unquestionable lineage
for the client.
BACK
TO TOP
|
|
Call 1-800-643-4303
for a FREE consultation of your research problem!
|